Australia: Recycled Platitudes Make Poor Debate - Australian

May 02, 2009


Media Watch presenter Jonathan Holmes's current obsession is the use of the word illegals by this newspaper and others in describing boatpeople. The Press Council, Holmes scolded, has 'passed on complaints this time around about the use of the word 'illegal' to a number of papers'. It has - ignoring the point that the vessels on which asylum seekers arrive are SIEVS, suspected illegal entry vessels. The Press Council would prefer us to splash with a snappy headline from commonwealth immigration legislation - 'unlawful non-citizens'.

Holmes's mantra was familiar. A Just Australia's national co-ordinator, Kate Gauthier, chants ad nauseam form the same songsheet. In repeated emails, Ms Gauthier has chided The Australian's editor, Paul Whittaker, urging him to 'caution' journalists for using the word 'illegals' and 'let me know of any action you intend to take'. Splitting hairs, the term 'unlawful entrants' would be acceptable to her. A Just Australia also riled against an article informing readers that 38 asylum seekers were 'well-dressed' (how dare we tell people?). Ms Gauthier cited a 'highly inflammatory' reference to 'sneaking in'. Those waiting for decades to enter Australia through official refugee programs might disagree vigorously with her view. Perhaps she will turn her politically correct wrath on Kevin Rudd next for referring to the 'illegal movement of persons' in a press conference last week. Tsk tsk.


The Australian


This entry is in the following archive(s): | |

More Immigration Stories From Australia

Australia: Imm. Minister expresses regrets over deportation of girl

May 15, 2009
The fact that a young girl was secretly deported to Iran while her father was being held in immigration detention is 'shocking', but it couldn't happen under Labor, Immigration Minister Chris Evans says. The child, known as Y, was removed...
Continue Reading

Australia: Business groups say immigration reductions could slow recovery

May 14, 2009
Cuts to Australia's record-high immigration program will rob the economy of more than half a billion dollars in potential revenue and could slow Australia's eventual recovery from recession. Business groups have criticised the cut to the permanent skilled migration program...
Continue Reading

Australia: Tourist industry laments rise in visa fees

May 14, 2009
The tourism industry has been dealt a hidden blow in the federal budget, the Tourism and Transport Forum says. Sharp rises in visa application fees could deter travellers to Australia at a time the country needed to do all it...
Continue Reading

Australia: Authorities used ruse to return detainee's daughter to Iran

May 14, 2009
Six years ago Immigration Department officials asked a 38-year-old Iranian draughtsman locked up in Baxter detention centre for permission to take his seven-year-old daughter to Port Augusta for a shopping trip. The man agreed. 'No problem,' he told staff. 'Yes,...
Continue Reading

Australia: Refugee advocates cheered by changes for asylum seekers

May 13, 2009
Refugee advocates have broadly supported a series of quiet changes to Australia's refugee regime made in Tuesday's budget, including increased working rights for asylum seekers. Also buried in the budget papers is an announcement formally creating a program to get...
Continue Reading

More Immigration Stories From Australian

Australia: Recycled Platitudes Make Poor Debate - Australian

May 02, 2009
Media Watch presenter Jonathan Holmes's current obsession is the use of the word illegals by this newspaper and others in describing boatpeople. The Press Council, Holmes scolded, has 'passed on complaints this time around about the use of the...
Continue Reading

More Immigration Stories From Opinion

'Secure'?: Another New Definition from Secretary Napolitano - Janice Kephart

May 16, 2009
By Janice Kephart On Wednesday, the House Homeland Security Committee conducted a hearing on the 2010 budget priorities of the Department of Homeland Security. The budget was submitted to Congress on May 7, 2009 as part of the President's $3.5...
Continue Reading

Secure Fences Work at White House - Jon Feere

May 16, 2009
By Jon Feere Open-border advocates often claim that fences don't work. Why, then, does the White House have a secure, dual perimeter fence (both metal and 'virtual') and limited points of entry-with officials doing quick background checks at each? Answer:...
Continue Reading

Pandering by the ADL - Stephen Steinlight

May 16, 2009
By Stephen Steinlight Notwithstanding the most incontrovertible survey data - findings so solid, consistent, and devastating not even the most naïve multicultural Pollyanna can be in denial regarding the fanatical anti-Semitism pervasive among the world's 1.3 billion Muslims - the...
Continue Reading

On E.J. Dionne's 'Buying Time on Immigration' - Stephen Steinlight

May 16, 2009
By Stephen Steinlight Before giving E.J. Dionne two cheers for the quotient of candor in his Washington Post column 'Buying Time on Immigration,' plus three cheers for calling for greater decency in the immigration debate, and a well deserved rap...
Continue Reading

The Change They Seek - John Wahala

May 16, 2009
By John Wahala The gathering here in Washington, D.C., had the predictable themes: an internationalist orientation; an array of Soviet-style paraphernalia; and the relentless recitation of Cesar Chavez's dictum, "Si se puede!" After an introduction in Spanish by the Rev....
Continue Reading